Day rate vs fixed price: who carries the risk
With a day rate, the customer pays for the time the job takes. If the floor is rotten under the old tiles, the extra two days are theirs to pay for. With a fixed price, you agree one figure for the whole job and the extra two days come out of your pocket. If you finish a day early, the saving is yours.
That's the whole trade-off. A day rate is safer for you and less certain for them. A fixed price is certain for them and only as safe for you as your estimate of the time. Neither is the honest one and neither is the greedy one; they put the same risk on different people, and the right choice depends on how much of the job you can see before you start.
When a day rate suits
A day rate is the fair answer when neither of you can know how long the job takes until it's under way.
- Repairs and fault finding, where the first hour decides what the next ten look like.
- Older properties, where opening up a wall or a floor is the only way to see what's behind it.
- Jobs the customer is designing as you go: 'while you're here', moving the sockets twice, changing the tiles after they've seen them on the wall.
- Labour-only work for another trade or a main contractor, where they supply the materials and direct the job.
- Small jobs strung together in one visit, where pricing each one separately would take longer than doing them.
When a fixed price suits
A fixed price suits a job with a clear scope that you've done often enough to know the time it takes: a boiler swap like the last twenty, a bathroom with a drawing and a tile choice, a rewire of a house you've surveyed. Householders tend to prefer it because they know what they're spending before they agree, and it often wins the job against a day rate for exactly that reason.
The price has to carry your risk. Work out the days you expect, price them at your day rate, then add an allowance for the things that usually go a little wrong. Then write down what the price includes and what it doesn't, so a genuine change to the job becomes an agreed extra rather than an argument.
A middle way works well on bigger jobs: a fixed price for everything you can see, and your day rate for anything you can't, named on the quote. 'Any work needed to the joists once the floor is up will be charged at the day rate, and agreed with you before it starts' is fair to both sides.
How to work out your day rate
Don't start from what the next trade charges. Start from what you need to earn, and work back. The steps are the same for everyone; only the figures change.
- Add up your yearly business costs: the van (finance or lease, fuel, insurance, servicing), tools and replacing them, your business insurance, phone, accountant, software, trade memberships, workwear.
- Decide the profit you need before tax: what you want to take home, plus the income tax and National Insurance on it. As a sole trader you pay Class 4 National Insurance on profits, and there's no employer paying you for holidays or sick days.
- Count the days you'll actually bill. Start from 260 weekdays, take off your holidays, the bank holidays, a few days for illness and the quiet weeks, then take off the time that earns nothing: quoting, buying materials, travelling between jobs, paperwork.
- Divide costs plus profit by the billable days. That's the lowest day rate that pays you what you set out to earn. Materials are charged on top, at the price you set for them.
A worked example, with made-up figures
This is an example only. Sam is made up, and so are his figures: they're there to show the arithmetic, not as a guide to what anyone should charge. Your costs, your area and your trade will all be different. His sums are laid out below.
Tax note for the example: in the 2026 to 2027 tax year, outside Scotland, profit of £40,000 with the full personal allowance of £12,570 and no other income means £27,430 taxed at 20% (£5,486.00 income tax) and Class 4 National Insurance at 6% on the same £27,430 (£1,645.80). That's £7,131.80 to set aside, leaving £32,868.20. Scotland has its own income tax bands, and rates and allowances can change at a Budget, so check gov.uk or ask your accountant for your own figures.
If Sam keeps his paid days up, £300 a day pays the costs and the profit. If quiet weeks cut him to 160 paid days, the same rate brings in £48,000, not £52,800, and the gap comes out of his profit. That's why the unpaid days matter as much as the costs.
Example only: Sam, a sole trader, made-up figures. Van finance, fuel, insurance and servicing: £8,500.00. Tools and replacing them: £1,500.00. Business insurance: £900.00. Phone, accountant, software, memberships, workwear: £1,900.00. Yearly costs: £12,800.00. Profit wanted before tax: £40,000.00. To cover in the year: £52,800.00. Weekdays: 260. Less holidays 20, bank holidays 8, illness 5, quiet weeks 7: 220 working days. Less one working day in five spent quoting, buying and travelling (44 days): 176 paid days. Day rate: £52,800.00 divided by 176 = £300.00 a day, plus materials.
Turning a day rate into a fixed price
Your day rate is also how you price a fixed job. Estimate the days, multiply, add the materials and an allowance for risk. Then watch what happens when the estimate is wrong.
Using Sam's made-up figures: a job he expects to take four days, quoted at £1,200 for labour, pays £300 a day if it takes four. If it takes five, he's earned £240 a day. If he finishes in three, he's earned £400 a day. A fixed price rewards the trade who knows his jobs well and punishes the one who guesses. Keep a note of how long jobs actually took against what you quoted; after a few months it tells you which jobs you underprice.
How to present a day rate so the customer isn't surprised
A day rate goes wrong when the customer hears '£X a day' and pictures a total that was never said. The fix is to put the rest of the picture in writing: what a day is, what's charged on top, how many days you expect, and when you'll tell them if it's running over.
For a householder this is also the law. Before a contract made in their home or at a distance, the Consumer Contracts Regulations 2013 require you to give the total price, or, where it can't reasonably be worked out in advance, the way it will be calculated. A day rate with the days you expect is exactly that.
Labour is charged at £300.00 a day (8am to 4pm on site, including travel within 10 miles). Half days are charged at half the day rate. Materials are charged separately at the prices shown on the quote. I expect the work to take 4 to 5 days. If it looks like taking longer, I'll tell you before the end of day 4, explain why, and agree it with you before carrying on. I'll invoice at the end of each week for the days worked.
A price agreed is the price
Whichever way you charge, what you tell a householder about the price becomes part of the contract. Under the Consumer Rights Act 2015, things you say or write about the service that the customer relies on in deciding to go ahead are terms of the contract. A fixed price is the price, even if the job ran long. A day rate is the agreed way of working out the price, and the number of days you said to expect is something they relied on, so if it's going to change, say so early and agree it.
If nothing fixed the price or said how it would be worked out, the customer only has to pay a reasonable price. And if you didn't agree when the work would be done, it has to be done within a reasonable time, which matters on a day rate: a customer paying by the day can fairly object to a job that drags. Our guide to quotes and estimates covers the difference between a firm figure and a best guess.